Title: The Silver Ladies Of Penny Lane
Author: Dee MacDonald
Genre: Contemporary, Romance
First published: April 24th 2019
Publisher: Bookouture
Finished reading: April 2nd 2019
Pages: 275
“These things usually happen when you aren’t looking for them.”
*** A copy of this book was kindly provided to me by Netgalley and Bookouture in exchange for an honest review. Thank you! ***
I was really looking forward to spend time with The Silver Ladies Of Penny Lane, especially since I loved the writing style and humor in The Getaway Girls last year. I was fully expecting to be having a blast while reading Dee MacDonald‘s newest title, but I guess it just wasn’t ment to be… And I turned out having a completely different reaction instead. It’s unpopular opinion time again! Because I ended up having quite a few issues with this story and surprisingly none had to do with the fact that the contemporary romance genre normally isn’t really for me. I’ll try to explain why The Silver Ladies Of Penny Lane didn’t work for me below.
The first and most important issue I had with this story had to do with one of Tess’ dates… More especifically the one in the hotel. I don’t want to give away too many details to avoid spoilers, but basically what is described can be considered rape. Disgusting enough on its own and trigger warning worthy, but to make things even worse Tess tries to justify it and blames herself? No, no, NO!! I nearly stopped reading there and then because of this scene. Another thing that bothered me considerably is that way this story completely destroys body positivity. I mean, Tess believing she has to lose weight in order for her to look good, be successful and find a man? Not only shallow but completely contradicts the image their own shop tries to portray. Characters in general are discriminated and talked about negatively because of their weight and appearance and this really left me with a sour taste in my mouth. The story itself is filled with cliches and not in a good way… I personally couldn’t even find the humor in them this time around. I also failed to connect to the main characters, mostly due to how they behaved and the negativity towards others. The dates themselves were so cliche that they are almost offensive and most characters really lacked fleshing out for me. A shame, because I was really looking forward to see more mature main characters for a change. What I did like? The writing does read quite fast and I loved the descriptions of the different places of their Greek cruise. This travel element was probably my favorite part of the story. Otherwise, unfortunately this turned out to be a rather disappointing journey for me. I do hope others will react differently to The Silver Ladies Of Penny Lane!
Tess and Orla have been best friend for a long time and have worked together in a dressmakers shop on the corner of Penny Lane for quite some time. Then one day, sixty-two-year-old Tess decides she wants something more out of the rest of her days and wants to rediscover herself… Hoping to find someone special to spend those days with sooner than later. Orla convinces her to join a dating agency, resulting in some very interesting meetings… And a cruise visiting the Greek islands on the menu as well.
I definitely wasn’t expecting to be having this reaction to The Silver Ladies Of Penny Lane, but it is what it is I guess… I turned out having various serious issues with this story, a lot relating to how characters behaved and were portrayed. I apologize if this review turned into a rant, but I really couldn’t help but getting my feelings out there since it doesn’t happen often I have this strong of a reaction to a story. I do hope others will have a better time with The Silver Ladies Of Penny Lane though.
You can also find me at Goodreads. Twitter. Instagram. Facebook. Bloglovin’.
Great post, as usual!
I was shaking my head as I was reading your review! Wear your unpopular opinions high and proud, love!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Someone has to have the unpopular opinions… And I seem to get them a lot haha. I’m sad I had this negative reaction to the story though, but it is what it is I guess
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yikes, unexpected rape scenes are never appreciated when I read, so thanks for the heads up. Can any of Tess’s attempts at justification be blamed on the fact that she’s from an older generation and that’s unfortunately what girls were taught to do? Is that addressed at all in the book? đŸ˜¦ I haven’t read this, but that just sounds…depressing and tragic.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It was even worse, because it wasn’t called rape at all in the book and no explanation was given other than the main character claiming ‘well, I did drink a lot so I guess it was my own fault’. Given a proper explanation or at least denouncing what happened would have probably made me react differently to the story.
LikeLiked by 1 person
What a shame you didn’t enjoy it as The Getaway Girls was hilarious!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I loved The Getaway Girls as well! That’s probably why I was so sad I ended up having such an extreme reaction to this one.
LikeLike
I appreciate your honesty!! Excellent review!
LikeLiked by 1 person
We can’t like them all I guess. đŸ˜‰
LikeLiked by 1 person
Sighhh…. I have lots of issues with this book…
LikeLiked by 1 person
While it’s a shame we had these feelings, it’s a relief I’m not the only one… I saw that they updated the file on Netgalley the other day; they might have changed some of our issues? Although it would take a mighty amount of rewriting and basically changing the whole plot for me to actually enjoy the story.
LikeLike
I downloaded the new copy too… It is the same.. So I have no idea what they changed on it. After the hotel scene… I stopped reading the updated version
LikeLiked by 1 person
That’s good to know… I didn’t download the updated version as I already reviewed it and I don’t really have time for a reread of a story I didn’t like at all in the first place…
LikeLike
I read 4 times đŸ™ˆđŸ™ˆ
LikeLike
Wow that’s a lot. xD
LikeLiked by 1 person